Skip to content
Investing

Bond Yields Are Surging. Why Aren't Stock Markets Falling?

The US 30-year yield is above 5 percent and Bund yields are at 15-year highs, yet the S&P 500 sits within 1 percent of a record. Growth, record profit margins and AI spending explain the gap.

The New York Stock Exchange building on Broad Street, seen from the steps of Federal Hall on Wall Street with crowds in the street below.
Photo: Arild Vågen / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Long-term government borrowing costs in the US, Germany, France, Britain and Japan have climbed to multi-year highs, in several cases the highest since 2008 or earlier, yet the S&P 500 sits within 1 percent of a record and Europe's STOXX 600 is up close to 10 percent this year. The reason lies less in how high yields are than in why they are rising.

Rising bond yields are normally bad news for shares. They raise the cost of borrowing for companies and households, and they lift the return investors can earn without taking equity risk, which lowers the price they are willing to pay for future profits. This week's sell-off in government bonds has so far broken that pattern. Understanding why helps explain both the resilience of stock markets and the specific conditions under which it could end.

How far yields have climbed

The sell-off deepened on Tuesday, 1 September, when benchmark yields across the developed world hit multi-year peaks on the same day. Japan's 10-year yield reached 3 percent for the first time since 1996, a milestone for a market that for decades anchored global fixed income.

BondYield reached on 1 SeptemberHighest since
US 30-year Treasury5.27%close to a 19-year high
US 10-year Treasuryabout 4.79%January 2025
UK 10-year gilt5.25%2008
French 10-year OATjust above 4.215%November 2008
German 10-year Bundabove 3.36%15-year high
Japanese 10-year JGB3.00%1996

The German 30-year yield also rose above 3.84 percent, its highest since 2011. In France, where the IMF projects gross government debt at 118.4 percent of GDP this year, 10-year borrowing costs have exceeded Italy's for much of the summer, a sign of a country-specific risk premium on top of the global move.

The US Treasury Department building in Washington at dusk, its columned facade lit from inside and the Albert Gallatin statue in front.
The US Treasury Department building in Washington at dusk, its columned facade lit from inside and the Albert Gallatin statue in front. Photo: Wisneyykarin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Stocks are still near their highs

Equity markets so far this year

  • 13% S&P 500 gain, less than 1% below its 13 August record
  • 9.5% STOXX 600 gain
  • 27%+ Nikkei 225 gain

Europe's benchmark closed at 649 on Thursday, helped by comments from Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller. Japan, where the 10-year yield has just reached its highest since 1996, has delivered the strongest equity returns of the three.

That is not what a classic bond market crisis looks like. In a crisis, investors dump government debt because they doubt the borrower or fear inflation, and they dump shares at the same time. Here, money is leaving bonds while equity indices hold close to their highs.

Growth, not panic, is doing most of the work in the US

The first part of the answer is that, in the United States, much of the rise reflects a strong economy. Long-term yields can be split into expected inflation and a real yield, which tends to track expectations for growth. When the real component does most of the rising, markets are pricing a stronger economy rather than a loss of faith in the currency or the borrower.

New York Fed President John Williams told CNBC that the climb in long-term yields mainly reflects a strong US economy and an outlook fuelled by heavy investment in artificial intelligence and data centres. Fed Chair Kevin Warsh made a similar point at Jackson Hole on 28 August. He noted that real consumer spending had grown by more than 2 percent over the past four quarters, that private domestic final purchases were rising at almost a 3 percent annual pace and that unemployment, at 4.1 percent, was low by historical standards.

"I would be hard pressed to describe broad financial conditions as restrictive," Warsh said. For equity investors that is a double-edged message. It confirms that the economy can bear current rates, but it also suggests the Fed may see room to tighten further.

Supply is the second part of the story. US national debt has passed $40 trillion, and governments from Washington to Tokyo keep borrowing heavily. A steady flow of new bonds has to find buyers, and investors ask for a higher yield to absorb it, without any loss of confidence in the economy itself. The US Treasury stepped into the market last month, saying it would at least double its buybacks of 10- to 30-year bonds, from $2 billion to $4 billion per operation, but yields later rose past their pre-announcement levels.

Europe's picture is less comfortable, because inflation is a bigger part of the story there. Euro-area inflation jumped to 3.3 percent in August from 2.9 percent in July, driven by an energy shock as the war in the Middle East and the closure of the Strait of Hormuz keep fuel costs high. Brent crude traded above $96 a barrel on Thursday. The European Central Bank raised its deposit rate to 2.25 percent on 11 June, its first increase in three years, and markets expect a further increase to 2.50 percent at its meeting on 10 September.

Record profits are absorbing the higher discount rate

The third and strongest support for shares is earnings. Higher yields raise the rate at which future profits are discounted, but if those profits are rising fast enough, prices can hold up.

What US second-quarter results showed

  • With 97 percent of S&P 500 companies reported, 86 percent beat earnings estimates and 77 percent beat revenue forecasts, according to FactSet data from 28 August
  • Blended earnings growth reached 52 percent, the fastest since the second quarter of 2021
  • Revenue grew 15.5 percent
  • The net profit margin hit 17 percent, the highest since FactSet began tracking it in 2009

Strong nominal growth also helps. The US 10-year yield remains below the pace of nominal US GDP growth and within the 4 to 5 percent range that Ed Yardeni, president of Yardeni Research, has long described as the old normal for bond yields. When an economy grows faster in cash terms than the government's cost of borrowing, debt burdens are easier to carry, and companies can pass on higher costs through rising sales.

Higher yields also cut both ways for European sectors. Banks and insurers tend to earn more when long-term rates rise, while property companies, utilities and other heavy borrowers are more exposed. A headline index can therefore hold steady even as money rotates beneath the surface.

The combination that would change the picture

The calm rests on one condition: that yields are rising because the economy is strong. The mix stock markets fear most is yields that keep rising while growth slows, earnings estimates are cut and inflation expectations accelerate. In that case, investors would face a higher discount rate and lower profits at the same time, with no offset.

Several tests arrive within days. The US jobs report for August is due on Friday afternoon European time. Waller said on Thursday he would wait for next week's inflation figures and would consider a rate rise if they came in hot. US inflation is already well above target: the personal consumption expenditures index, the Fed's preferred gauge, rose 3.7 percent in the year to July, with core prices up 3.3 percent. The Fed held its target range at 3.50 to 3.75 percent in July, when three regional presidents voted for an increase.

The ECB decides on 10 September and the Fed on 16 September, its first meeting since Warsh said policy was not restrictive. If the data show growth holding up and profits still rising, the current truce between bonds and equities can last. If inflation surprises on the upside while growth softens, the gap between the two markets would become much harder to sustain.

Sources

Related stories

Investing

Gold Loses Its Shine as Rising Yields and Fed Hike Bets Bite

Spot gold fell about 1.8 percent this week to around $4,349 an ounce as 10-year Treasury yields neared 5 percent and futures priced a 90 percent chance of a Fed rate rise next…

Investing

Why France Now Pays More to Borrow Than Italy: The OAT Sell-Off Explained

France's 10-year yield hit 4.92 percent, the highest since 2002, and its premium over Germany reached 152 basis points, the widest since 2011. France now pays more to borrow than…

Markets

US 10-Year Yield Hits a 24-Year High as Treasury Sells 10-Year Debt at 5.30%

The US 10-year Treasury yield reached 5.361 percent, its highest since 2002, before a $39 billion auction cleared at 5.300 percent with foreign and other indirect buyers taking 80…

Investing

JPMorgan Misses as Bond Trading Slows While Goldman and Citi Shine

JPMorgan earned $5.57 a share in the third quarter, short of the $5.93 expected, as bond trading slowed. Goldman Sachs, Citigroup and Wells Fargo all beat forecasts.

Investing

Aya Gold & Silver Corrects Q3 Cash Costs to $14.28 an Ounce After Silver Double Count

Aya Gold & Silver refiled its Q3 MD&A after silver in transit was deducted twice. Zgounder ounces sold rise to 1,392,478 and cash costs fall to $14.28 from $15.51. Revenue and…

Investing

FDA Rejects Summit's Lung Cancer Drug Ivonescimab Over Phase 3 Survival Miss

The FDA has rejected Summit Therapeutics' lung cancer drug ivonescimab, saying slower tumour growth in the phase 3 HARMONi trial was not enough without a clear gain in survival.

Investing

Red Cat Withdraws Its $150m to $180m 2026 Revenue Target After $11.8m Third Quarter

Red Cat Holdings has withdrawn its $150m to $180m revenue target for 2026 after third-quarter sales of $11.8m, blaming slower defence funding. Its quarterly net loss more than…

Investing

Berkshire Reveals $689m Bending Spoons Stake, Doubles Lennar and Trims Bank of America Again

Berkshire Hathaway's third-quarter 13F shows a new Bending Spoons stake worth $689m, a doubled Lennar holding and 27.5 million more Bank of America shares sold, while Apple stayed…