Britain's financial regulator wants workplace pension providers to be able to pay certain performance fees without counting them against the 0.75% charge cap. The aim is to open default funds to private equity, venture capital and private credit, but the Financial Conduct Authority insists savers must get more value for any extra cost.
What the FCA Is Proposing
The FCA published consultation paper CP26/40 on 12 November. It proposes excluding certain performance-linked fees from the charge cap that applies to default funds in the workplace pensions it regulates.
Those are contract-based schemes, such as group personal pensions, run by insurers and other providers. A default fund is where a saver's contributions go if they never choose an investment themselves.
The cap, introduced in 2015, limits what these default funds can charge to 0.75% of the money invested each year. On a pot of £40,000, that is at most £300 a year in charges. Performance fees, which a fund manager earns only when returns beat an agreed level, are common in private markets but sit awkwardly with a hard cap, because they are unpredictable in advance.
The regulator's case is that taking these fees out of the cap calculation would let providers reach a wider range of investments that could improve long-term returns. Therese Chambers, the FCA's executive director of enforcement and market integrity, said the regulator wanted savings to work harder for people and providers to have more choice over how they invest for the long term.
Private equity, venture capital and private credit are the main targets. These are stakes in unlisted companies, funding for young businesses and loans made outside the bond market, all areas where managers typically take a share of the gains on top of a base fee.
The proposal in numbers
- 0.75% annual charge cap on default funds today
- 2.1% median rise in savers' net returns over ten years, in FCA modelling
- 14 January 2027 deadline for responses
Catching Up With Trust-Based Schemes
The change would bring the FCA's rules closer to those for trust-based workplace schemes, which are overseen by the Pensions Regulator. The Department for Work and Pensions has allowed those schemes to exclude certain performance fees from the cap, with protections for members, since 2023.
The FCA says its version builds on that 2023 change, reflects how private markets have developed since, and strengthens protections in areas such as how investments are valued. It also argues that matching the two regimes more closely would reduce complexity for providers that operate in both parts of the market, and support competition and choice.
The cost benefit analysis in the consultation paper estimates a median increase of 2.1% in net returns to savers over ten years, assuming providers put more into private markets. That is broadly in line with an earlier DWP estimate that a portfolio with 15% in private markets could deliver a pension pot up to 2% larger.
The Safeguards Attached
Using the exemption would be optional. Providers could choose to take it up, and the FCA says they should do so only where it is in savers' interests and they can meet the protections set out in the paper.
What providers would have to show
- Transparency about the performance fees charged and how they work.
- A fair allocation of fees between savers, so one group does not pay for another's gains.
- Proper scrutiny of how private assets, which do not trade daily, are valued.
- Enough information for providers and their Independent Governance Committees to judge whether the fees offer value for money.
The valuation point matters because performance fees are calculated on returns, and returns on unlisted assets depend on how those assets are priced. A generous valuation can trigger a fee that a later, lower valuation would not have justified.
Chambers also warned that "greater flexibility is not a licence to charge more". She added that any higher charges would have to be justified by additional value for savers.
What Happens Next
The consultation closes on 14 January 2027. The FCA will then consider the responses and expects to publish final rules in summer 2027. The regulator lists the work as a priority in its pensions regulatory priorities report, as part of wider pension reform.
For savers, nothing changes yet. If the rules go ahead, a default fund could hold more private market assets, and the cap figure on a statement would no longer capture every cost when performance fees are paid. How much of that flows through to pots will depend on how many providers choose to use the exemption, and on whether the private assets they buy deliver the returns that justify the fees.
Sources
- FCA proposes greater pension investment flexibility to support long-term value for savers (Financial Conduct Authority, 12 November 2026)
- CP26/40: Exempting performance fees from the workplace pensions charge cap (Financial Conduct Authority, 12 November 2026)
- Consultation Paper CP26/40, including cost benefit analysis (Financial Conduct Authority, November 2026)






