Skip to content
Markets

UnitedHealth Sinks 10% and Humana 13% Over a Medicare Audit Rule Worth $9bn a Year

UnitedHealth fell 10.21% and Humana 12.98% on 18 November after Medicare's regulator proposed applying audit errors to whole contracts back to 2018, which CMS says would recover $9bn a year.

Humana's red-brick office building beside Witherspoon Street in downtown Louisville, Kentucky, photographed in February 2008
Photo: Angry Aspie / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

UnitedHealth shares fell 10.21% and Humana 12.98% on Wednesday 18 November, a second day of heavy losses for US health insurers after Medicare's regulator proposed a tougher way to claw back overpayments. The CRUSH proposal would let auditors apply the error rate found in a small sample of Medicare Advantage patients to a whole contract, starting with payment year 2018, and CMS puts the haul at about $9bn a year.

The audit rule in numbers

  • $9bn average yearly recovery CMS expects from extrapolated Medicare Advantage audits
  • 15.1% UnitedHealth's two-day fall, from $412.02 on Monday to $349.91
  • 12.98% Humana's drop on Wednesday, the steepest among the big insurers

Why UnitedHealth and Humana shares fell two days running

The selling hit every big company running Medicare Advantage plans, the private alternative to traditional Medicare in which insurers cover older Americans and are paid by the government per member.

InsurerTuesday 17 NovemberWednesday 18 NovemberWednesday close
Humana-3.88%-12.98%$385.78
UnitedHealth-5.42%-10.21%$349.91
Elevance Health-2.77%-7.63%$400.84
Centene-2.97%-7.03%$67.45

Humana lost 16.4% over the two sessions. The wider market held up better: the S&P 500 slipped 0.2% for a fifth straight loss, its longest losing run since June, according to the Associated Press, a streak that took in Monday's slide in chip stocks. The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 561.25 points, or 1.1%, to 50,198.17.

Sign for the US Department of Health and Human Services outside the Hubert H. Humphrey Building in Washington, February 2025.
Sign for the US Department of Health and Human Services outside the Hubert H. Humphrey Building in Washington, February 2025. Photo: G. Edward Johnson / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

What the CMS CRUSH proposal would change for Medicare Advantage

On Monday 16 November the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued a proposed rule called Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, or CRUSH. Most of it targets fraud by providers, equipment suppliers and brokers. The part that moved the shares concerns Risk Adjustment Data Validation (RADV) audits.

Medicare Advantage insurers are paid more for sicker members: each diagnosis a plan records can raise a member's "risk score", and with it the payment. A RADV audit checks a sample of medical records to see whether those diagnoses are backed up.

According to the CMS fact sheet, the agency would begin extrapolating audit findings with payment year 2018 audits and would not apply a fee-for-service adjuster. That adjuster was meant to keep plans' payments in line with traditional Medicare, a principle known as actuarial equivalence, Healthcare Dive has explained.

"Every taxpayer dollar lost to fraud is a dollar that cannot support the care these programs were created to provide," CMS Administrator Dr Mehmet Oz said in the agency's press release.

How extrapolated audits could hit insurers' earnings

Without extrapolation, an insurer repays only the unsupported payments found in the sampled records. With it, the error rate from the sample is applied to every member of the contract. Put simply, if one sampled dollar in ten was unsupported, CMS could seek back roughly a tenth of the whole contract's payments.

CMS estimates the approach would recover an average of about $9bn of overpayments per payment year. Its earlier version of the rule was expected to bring in about $4.7bn over ten years, according to Healthcare Dive.

Money handed back comes straight off insurers' revenue, and reaching back to 2018 could reopen payments booked years ago. Mizuho analyst Ann Hynes named UnitedHealth and Humana as the most exposed, followed by CVS Health, Elevance Health, Centene and Molina Healthcare, FX Leaders reported. UnitedHealth runs the country's largest Medicare Advantage business, and Healthcare Dive describes Humana as the second-largest payer in the programme.

Why a court struck down the similar 2023 audit rule

CMS has tried this before. A RADV rule finalised in February 2023 also dropped the adjuster and allowed extrapolation back to 2018. Humana sued, and on Thursday 25 September 2025 Judge Reed O'Connor of the US District Court for the Northern District of Texas vacated the rule.

His objection was about process rather than the idea itself. He found that CMS had given no meaningful notice of its reasoning for dropping the adjuster, and wrote that "Plaintiffs, and others, will potentially bear enormous unforeseen costs," Healthcare Dive reported. Healthcare Dive and the law firm Groom Law Group both noted that CMS could start again with fresh notice and comment. CRUSH is that new attempt, which is why the market is taking it seriously.

When the CRUSH comment period ends and what happens next

CRUSH is a proposal, not a final rule. CMS says comments are due by Tuesday 19 January 2027, after which it can change, finalise or drop it.

The pressure is political too. Senator Elizabeth Warren has called for breaking up vertically integrated health groups, naming UnitedHealth, CVS and Cigna, FX Leaders reported. That call carries more weight after Democrats won both chambers of Congress earlier this month. Our markets coverage follows the insurers as the comment period runs.

Why did UnitedHealth and Humana stock drop?

UnitedHealth fell 10.21% and Humana 12.98% on Wednesday 18 November after CMS proposed extrapolating Medicare Advantage audit errors across whole contracts from payment year 2018, which it says would recover about $9bn a year.

What is the CMS CRUSH rule?

CRUSH (CMS-6098-P) is an anti-fraud proposal CMS issued on Monday 16 November covering Medicare, Medicaid and the ACA Marketplace, which it says would save nearly $90bn from 2027 to 2036.

Is the Medicare Advantage audit rule final?

No. CRUSH is a proposal, with comments due by 19 January 2027. A federal court vacated a similar rule in September 2025.

Sources

Related stories

The New York Stock Exchange and Federal Hall at the corner of Wall Street and Broad Street, August 2017
Markets

Dow Falls 561 Points as the S&P 500 Slips for a Fifth Day and Nvidia Reverses

The Dow fell 561 points to 50,198.17 on Wednesday and the S&P 500 slipped 0.2% for a fifth straight loss, its longest since June, as Nvidia turned an early 2.7% jump into a 2.89%…

Deutsche Bank's twin-tower headquarters with dark glass facades in Frankfurt's banking district, 2025
Markets

Deutsche Bank Shares Slide More Than 6% as a 15 Million-File Leak Revives Its Epstein Ties

Deutsche Bank shares fell more than 6% on Tuesday after a leak of over 15 million files said it flagged $581.9m of Epstein-linked payments. The bank says the matters are old.

The main entrance to Nvidia's headquarters at 2788-2888 San Tomas Expressway in Santa Clara, California, photographed in September 2022
Markets

Bessent Urges an Outside CEO for Nvidia as Shares Fall 4.1% Before Results

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent wants Nvidia to hire an outside chief executive, the board is not discussing Jensen Huang's return, and the shares fell 4.1% on Monday, a day…

The Alameda Avenue entrance to the Walt Disney Studios, Disney's headquarters in Burbank, California
Markets

Disney Raises Its Dividend 33% and Targets $3bn of Savings as Quarterly Revenue Rises 16%

Disney beat forecasts with fourth-quarter revenue up 16% to $25.9bn and adjusted earnings of $1.77 a share, raised its dividend 33% to $2.00 and targets about $3bn of yearly…

The marble Eccles Building, the Federal Reserve's headquarters in Washington, DC, under a blue sky in March 2011
Markets

Two-Year Treasury Yield Sinks to 4.63% as Traders Erase a Whole Fed Hike in One Week

The two-year Treasury yield fell 25 basis points in a week to 4.63% as stocks slumped, and traders cut the Fed hikes priced through late 2027 to 61 basis points from 86.

General Mills sign and entrance road at its world headquarters in Golden Valley, Minnesota, under grey clouds in May 2018
Markets

General Mills and McCormick Climb as the S&P 500 Sinks 3.7%, and Cereal Beats Chips

General Mills rose 3.7% and McCormick 3.4% on Friday 20 November as the S&P 500 fell 3.7%, while Tyson Foods and Hormel were the index's best two stocks in its worst week since…

The New York Stock Exchange building in New York, with marble columns and three US flags, May 2024
Markets

PCE Inflation, GDP and the Beige Book Land on One Day as Wall Street Limps Into Thanksgiving

US PCE inflation, forecast at 3.8%, lands on Wednesday 25 November with Q3 GDP, durable goods and the Beige Book, the Fed's last inflation read before its 8-9 December meeting.

Screens showing stock market data and technical charts inside the Taiwan Stock Exchange in Taipei, February 2021
Markets

Taiwan Shuts Short Sellers Out of Falling Stocks After the Taiex Loses 17.5% in a Week

Taiwan's FSC will bar short sales below the previous close on every listed stock from Monday 23 November and lift short-sale margin to 150%, after the Taiex lost 17.5% in one week.