Skip to content
Personal finance

Car Finance Compensation: Should You Take Your Lender's Settlement Offer?

With the FCA's motor finance scheme partly on hold until court hearings in early 2027, lenders may now make early settlement offers. Accepting one closes the claim for good. Here is what to weigh.

Cars for sale on the forecourt of a Suzuki dealership in Romford, England, under a sign advertising 0% finance.
Photo: Stacey Harris / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Millions of UK drivers who took out car finance between 2007 and 2024 are owed money under the Financial Conduct Authority's compensation scheme, but legal challenges mean payments are on hold until at least next year. On 3 November the regulator said lenders may now make early settlement offers, as long as customers get no less than the scheme would pay. Here is how those offers work, and what claimants may want to weigh before replying.

The choice is simple to describe and harder to make: take a known sum now and close the claim for good, or wait for the courts and keep the chance of a different outcome.

Why the Scheme Is on Hold

The FCA confirmed its motor finance compensation scheme in March. It covers loans taken out between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024 where customers were treated unfairly, mainly through three practices: discretionary commission arrangements, where a dealer or broker could raise the interest rate to earn more commission; high commission, meaning at least 39% of the total cost of credit and 10% of the loan; and tied arrangements, where a dealer or broker used only one lender or gave one lender first refusal.

The FCA scheme in numbers

  • 12.1m car finance agreements estimated to be eligible
  • £7.5bn estimated total compensation if 75% of eligible customers claim
  • £830 approximate average payment per agreement

Compensation is usually calculated as the average of the commission paid and an estimated loss based on a discount to the loan's APR, with interest added at the Bank of England's average base rate plus one point, and at least 3% a year.

On 2 July, the Upper Tribunal suspended parts of the scheme while it hears challenges brought by Consumer Voice, a claimant group represented by Courmacs Legal, and by three lenders: Volkswagen Financial Services, Mercedes-Benz Financial Services and Crédit Agricole Auto Finance. The hearings are now due to run between 16 February and 3 March 2027.

Until they conclude, lenders must keep preparing and progressing complaints, but they do not have to calculate or pay compensation. The FCA has said payments could begin in 2027 if the scheme is upheld and not appealed, and could slip to 2028 or beyond if it is overturned and a revised scheme is challenged again.

Glass office towers at 12 Endeavour Square in Stratford, east London, the address of the Financial Conduct Authority's headquarters.
Glass office towers at 12 Endeavour Square in Stratford, east London, the address of the Financial Conduct Authority's headquarters. Photo: Yirba / Wikimedia Commons, CC0

How a Settlement Offer Works

The new guidance does not force anyone to settle. It sets the conditions a lender must meet if it chooses to make an offer before the legal process ends.

The FCA's conditions for settlement offers

  • The offer must give the customer at least what they would receive under the scheme.
  • The lender must explain that accepting is final: the customer keeps the money even if the legal outcome would have paid less, and cannot claim more if it would have paid more.
  • The lender must send the FCA's factsheet on settlement offers with the offer.
  • Lenders must tell the FCA before making offers, and the FCA will list them on its website so customers can check an offer is genuine.

Barclays Partner Finance has said it will make settlement offers to some of its customers who are owed compensation. Other lenders may follow, and the FCA's published list is the place to confirm who is taking part.

One detail matters for anyone hoping to keep a backstop. Settlement offers cannot be referred to the Financial Ombudsman Service, because customers can always turn an offer down and stay in the scheme. Rejecting an offer simply leaves the customer in the scheme.

The FCA's general counsel, Stephen Braviner Roman, said: "Fair settlement offers could result in some people getting money sooner." He added that customers who want to wait are under no obligation to agree.

Taking the Money Now or Waiting

The regulator's survey work suggests many claimants want the option. In a Kantar poll of 1,000 motor finance customers carried out online between 25 and 28 June, the findings for the 590 who had complained or were considering it were striking.

Survey finding (590 customers)Share
Want the choice of an offer now rather than waiting89%
Would be comfortable making that decision86%
Say earlier payment would make a great deal or fair amount of difference to their finances77%
Would accept an offer in line with the scheme61%

The trade-off works in both directions, which is why the decision depends on each household's circumstances rather than a general rule.

An early offer gives certainty. Under the FCA's conditions the amount cannot be lower than the scheme would pay on its current rules, and the money arrives months or possibly years sooner. For a household that would use the money to pay down expensive debt, the timing alone can be worth a lot.

Waiting keeps options open. The legal challenges come from both a claimant group and three lenders, so a ruling could move the scheme in either direction. Payments under a revised scheme could end up higher or lower than today's rules imply, and the timetable could stretch further. Anyone who accepts an offer gives up any upside from a ruling in favour of claimants, but is also protected from any downside.

Practical Points Before You Reply

Whatever you decide, a few points from the FCA's guidance apply to everyone with a possible claim.

What the FCA says claimants should know

  • Complaining directly to the lender is free; a law firm or claims company is not needed.
  • Claims firms can take up to 36% of any compensation, including VAT.
  • People who have not complained and are not contacted by a lender can still claim until 31 August 2027.
  • Customers can simply wait for the scheme outcome rather than accept an offer.

The claims firm point is easy to underestimate. On a payment close to the scheme's £830 average, a 36% fee would take almost £300 of it. Customers who signed up with a claims firm before the scheme was confirmed may want to check the terms of that agreement before an offer arrives.

It also pays to treat unexpected offers with care. Because the FCA will publish the names of lenders that are making settlement offers, checking that list before replying is a simple way to confirm that an offer is genuine.

Finally, the scheme's other deadlines are still running. Lenders must tell complainants with agreements from 1 April 2014 who are not owed compensation by 18 November 2026, if they complained by 30 June. For agreements before April 2014, the deadline is 18 January 2027 for complaints made by 31 August 2026.

What Happens Next

The next milestones are the FCA's list of lenders making offers, which it will keep updated, and the Upper Tribunal hearings in February and March 2027. A ruling after those hearings will decide whether the scheme proceeds as designed, is changed or has to be rebuilt. Until then, the settlement route gives customers a choice they did not have before, and it is a choice nobody is obliged to make.

Sources

Related stories

Personal finance

UK Mortgage Approvals Stuck Below 60,000 as Savills Sees House Prices Falling 1.5% in 2027

With fixed rates around 6 percent, UK mortgage approvals have been under 60,000 for five months. Savills now expects prices to fall 1.5 percent in 2027, led by London, as some…

Markets

Global Bond Rout: French Yields Hit a 24-Year High and UK 30-Year Gilts Top 6%

France's 10-year yield hit 4.96 percent, its highest since 2002, the UK 30-year gilt broke 6 percent for the first time since 1998, and Treasuries had their worst quarter since…

Personal finance

FCA Moves to Let Workplace Pensions Pay Performance Fees Outside the 0.75% Charge Cap

The UK regulator wants contract-based workplace pensions to pay private equity and venture capital performance fees outside the 0.75% cap on default funds. Responses are due by 14…

Personal finance

Why Eurozone Variable Mortgage Payments Keep Rising Even as the ECB Pauses

The ECB held rates on 29 October, yet many variable-rate borrowers will still pay more at their next review, some by over €100 a month. How Euribor and annual resets turn a pause…

Personal finance

UK Mortgage Approvals Stuck Below 60,000 as Savills Sees House Prices Falling 1.5% in 2027

With fixed rates around 6 percent, UK mortgage approvals have been under 60,000 for five months. Savills now expects prices to fall 1.5 percent in 2027, led by London, as some…

Personal finance

Spanish Pensions Set for About a 3.5% Rise in 2027 as Inflation Holds at 4.9%

Spain's statistics office confirmed October inflation at 4.9 percent, locking in a pension rise of about 3.5 percent for January. The average retirement pension would gain some €55…

Personal finance

FCA Moves to Let Workplace Pensions Pay Performance Fees Outside the 0.75% Charge Cap

The UK regulator wants contract-based workplace pensions to pay private equity and venture capital performance fees outside the 0.75% cap on default funds. Responses are due by 14…

Personal finance

Diesel Still 32% Dearer Across the EU Than Before the Iran War, Even as Pump Prices Ease

The EU average diesel price fell 2.6% on the week to €2.097 a litre on 9 November, but it is still 31.6% above late February. Petrol is up 14.7%, and drivers in Finland and Denmark…