Skip to content
Economy

Moody's Spares France a Downgrade but Keeps Its Outlook Negative

Moody's left France at Aa3 with a negative outlook, defying expectations of a cut to A1, but made the rating depend on a 2027 budget that cuts the deficit to 5 percent of GDP.

The French Ministry of the Economy and Finance at Bercy in Paris, its long concrete building reaching out over the Seine.
Photo: Fred Romero / Flickr, CC BY 2.0

Moody's left France's sovereign rating at Aa3 with a negative outlook on Friday evening, defying widespread expectations of a cut to A1. The agency tied the decision to an assumption that Paris adopts a 2027 budget that brings the deficit down.

A reprieve the market had not priced

Many investors had treated a downgrade as the central case. Théophile Legrand, a rates strategist at Natixis, had called a cut the central scenario and argued it was largely anticipated by markets. After the announcement he described the outcome as a short-term surprise, welcome for both the government and investors.

The negative outlook keeps the threat alive. It signals that Moody's still sees the next move as more likely down than up, and Legrand warned that the risk of a downgrade remains fully present. The agency made its assumption explicit: the rating rests on a 2027 budget that reduces the deficit being adopted, and on funding costs and social tensions easing somewhat in the coming months.

Moody's last cut France in December 2024, to Aa3, and had confirmed that rating with a negative outlook at its review on 10 April. A move to A1 would have brought it level with the other two large agencies.

AgencyRatingOutlookLatest review
Moody'sAa3Negative23 October 2026, unchanged
FitchA+Stable28 August 2026
S&P GlobalA+Stable29 May 2026, next due 27 November

That leaves Moody's as the only one of the three that still places France in the double-A category, one notch above the others.

The Bercy finance ministry building in Paris rising above the stone balustrade and arches of the Pont de Bercy.
The Bercy finance ministry building in Paris rising above the stone balustrade and arches of the Pont de Bercy. Photo: Fred Romero / Flickr, CC BY 2.0

Paris claims vindication, but the budget is still unwritten

Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu wrote on X that the decision confounded the gloomy forecasts of many so-called experts and of those speculating on French debt. Economy Minister Roland Lescure called it recognition of the economy's strength and of the budget's credibility, and said adopting a budget by the end of the year that cuts the deficit to 5 percent of GDP is non-negotiable.

The arithmetic is demanding. The 2027 draft targets a deficit of 5.0 percent of GDP, down from an expected 5.4 percent this year, through an effort of roughly €54 billion: about €43 billion in new measures and €11 billion already decided.

Parliament is not cooperating. On Friday the National Assembly rejected the revenue half of the 2027 social security budget by 115 votes to 1. Public Accounts Minister David Amiel said the social security deficit had worsened by more than €5 billion since debate on the bill began, and singled out the National Rally for criticism. The Assembly votes on the revenue half of the main state budget on 3 November.

Bonds and shares under strain

The rating call came at the end of a punishing week for French assets. On Thursday the 10-year government bond yield rose 11 basis points to 5.113 percent, its highest since 2002 and above the US 10-year Treasury yield for the first time since 2013. Before the US-Iran war began, the same yield stood at 3.2 percent.

The gap over German Bunds is at its widest since November 2011, with the German 10-year yield near 3.4 percent. Jérôme Mathis, an economics professor at Paris-Dauphine University, said the widening spread reflects a loss of confidence specific to France, and warned that resistance to spending cuts could push the risk premium higher still.

Street unrest has added to the pressure. Nationwide marches on 17 October were followed by rioting and looting in several cities, with about 2,400 arrests and at least 3,000 shops damaged. Carrefour estimated the cost of the looting at €80 million to €200 million, and its shares fell more than 13 percent. Luxury groups Kering and Hermès also fell sharply, and the CAC 40 is down 4.5 percent over the past month.

Four dates that decide the next move

The reprieve buys time rather than confidence. Jérémie Peloso, chief Europe strategist at BCA Research, said the government and the presidential candidates lack budget ambition, with the presidential election less than six months away.

Protest groups called a second day of action for Saturday 24 October, and the government is deploying 20 percent more police for the weekend. After that, the 3 November vote on the state budget's revenues is the first real test of whether a deficit-cutting budget can pass at all. S&P's scheduled review follows on 27 November, and the government aims to have the 2027 budget adopted by the end of the year.

If that budget fails, the condition Moody's attached to Friday's decision fails with it. For bondholders, that makes the coming weeks of parliamentary votes more important than the rating itself.

Sources

Related stories

Markets

Hermès Growth Slows to 4.3% in the Third Quarter as Ready-to-Wear Falls and Asia Stalls

Hermès shares fell as much as 7.6% in Paris after third-quarter sales growth slowed to 4.3% at constant rates, below the 5.2% expected, as ready-to-wear shrank and Asia outside…

Business

Carrefour Cuts 2026 Targets After Riots and Looting Hit French Stores

Carrefour cut its 2026 earnings, cash flow and investment targets after riots hit about 50 French stores, putting the cost to operating income at €80 million to €200 million.

Investing

The French Stocks Most Exposed to Riots, Curfews and the Budget Standoff

The CAC 40 has lost 4.5 percent in a month as riots, curfews and a budget fight push France's 10-year yield above 5.1 percent. Retail, luxury, banks and property are the most…

Business

Kering Shares Plunge as Gucci Sales Slide 6% on Weak Asian Traffic

Kering shares fell 11.5 percent after Gucci's third-quarter sales dropped 6 percent on a comparable basis to €1.29 billion, and the group did not repeat its goal of returning to…

Economy

Fed and ECB Warn the AI Boom Is Turning to Debt as Top AI Firms Head Past $800bn

Fed Governor Michael Barr said debt at the seven largest AI firms should top $800bn this year, as the ECB's Boris Vujčić said AI and sovereign debt now stand out among euro area…

Economy

China's Retail Sales Grow Just 0.4% in October as Investment Falls 8.1% and Exports Surge

China's retail sales grew just 0.4% in October and fixed-asset investment fell 8.1% over ten months, official data showed, leaving exports to carry an economy with weak demand at…

Economy

China's New-Home Prices Fell in 49 of 70 Cities in October as Resale Prices Slid in 58

New-home prices in China fell on the month in 49 of 70 cities in October and resale prices in 58, official data show, while retail sales grew just 0.4% as cautious households held…

Economy

Japan's Economy Shrinks at a 0.1% Annual Rate as BoJ's Takata Calls for Nimble Rate Rises

Japan's economy shrank at an annualised 0.1% in July to September, its first fall in a year, as prices hit shoppers. The same day BoJ board member Hajime Takata urged nimble rate…