Skip to content
Investing

Allied Critical Metals Retracts 'Robust' Tungsten Claims and Shows a Minus C$183m Case

After a BC Securities Commission review, Allied Critical Metals retracted its 'Robust' Borralha tungsten PEA wording and disclosed an after-tax NPV of minus C$183m at US$400/mtu.

Pale spoil heap of the old Borralha tungsten mines in a wooded valley in northern Portugal, July 2019
Photo: MartaLVRZ / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Allied Critical Metals has withdrawn the "Robust" label from its study of the Borralha tungsten project in Portugal after a British Columbia Securities Commission review. On Friday 20 November the CSE-listed company also published the downside its headlines left out: at US$400 per tonne unit of tungsten, the after-tax net present value is minus C$183.0m, against a C$182.7m base case.

Borralha after the BCSC review

  • C$182.7m after-tax NPV in the US$704/mtu base case, unchanged
  • minus C$183.0m after-tax NPV at US$400/mtu, with no payback within the mine life
  • 8 paid investor relations and marketing contracts listed in the same release

What Allied Critical Metals retracted after the BCSC review

The company said the review found ambiguous statements in its news releases, its third-quarter 2026 presentation and its website under NI 43-101, the Canadian rule on how miners describe their projects.

Out goes the "Robust Initial PEA" headline of Monday 2 March and chief executive Roy Bonnell's line that the study confirmed Borralha as "a high-return, capital-efficient tungsten development project". A preliminary economic assessment (PEA) is an early study, and this one leans partly on inferred resources, the least certain kind.

The presentation took the bigger hit. Allied retracted its PEA results, old Vila Verde estimates shown as if current, and any hint that it had decided to build either mine or a Vila Verde pilot plant. It has made no such decision, it said. Yet its annual report of 9 October spoke of "the decision to commence production at the Vila Verde Pilot Plant". The slides also failed to name the qualified person behind them: Vítor Arezes, vice president of exploration.

Stone smelter building of the former Borralha tungsten mines among pine trees in northern Portugal, July 2019.
Stone smelter building of the former Borralha tungsten mines among pine trees in northern Portugal, July 2019. Photo: MartaLVRZ / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

How the Borralha PEA changes at lower tungsten prices

The March release led with the US$1,000 case, and a second release on Tuesday 10 March repeated it as "Robust Core PEA Economics Maintained". Allied now concedes the upside needed matching downside beside it.

Tungsten price (US$/mtu WO3)After-tax NPV (8%)IRRPayback from constructionHeadlined in March?
306minus C$319.6mnot reportednot achievedNo
400minus C$183.0mnot reportednot achievedNo
704 (Argus base case)C$182.7m27.2%5.8 yearsYes
1,000C$473.4m48.8%4.2 yearsYes, lead case
1,500C$963.8m78.4%3.2 yearsYes

The awkward detail is cost. In March Allied put all-in sustaining cost, the running cost including upkeep, at about US$303/mtu, yet at US$306 the project is deeply negative. Friday's release explains why: these are benchmark prices, payability and refining charges cut revenue, and the NPV must repay initial capital the study put at about US$91m, give or take 35%. No break-even price is given.

The bull case for Borralha

The prices Allied cites sit far above the study: a Fastmarkets figure of about US$1,998/mtu for 27 February, and an April range of US$2,800 to US$3,280/mtu for ammonium paratungstate, a refined tungsten product. Borralha holds 13.0 million tonnes of measured and indicated resources at 0.21% WO3 plus 7.7 million tonnes inferred at 0.18%, with a conditional favourable environmental impact declaration since January. The annual report adds a US$15m debt facility for the Vila Verde pilot plant and an offtake for half its expected concentrate, with a 2026 floor of US$1,000/mtu.

The company says China, Russia and North Korea account for about 87% of global tungsten supply and reserves, which is why western projects such as Nevada tungsten developer Guardian Metal Resources draw attention.

The bear case: dilution, cash burn and paid promotion

Allied last traded at C$0.73 on Friday, down 7.6%, according to CSE data, against the C$2.05 Tribeca Investment Partners paid in September and a 52-week high of C$2.48. With 195,052,313 shares out at 9 October, that is about C$142m, before 16.09m warrants and 13.87m options. Cash was C$24.0m on 30 June, before C$21.15m gross from Tribeca. In the year to June it used C$11.0m in operations and lost C$28.7m, including C$18.7m of share-based pay.

Friday's release also lists who is paid to spread the story:

Allied's disclosed marketing contracts

  • Native Ads: US$200,000 over 24 months; Streetwise Reports: US$50,500; BTV: C$15,300 plus US$38,000 for TV spots
  • Market One Media: C$150,000 for features on BNN Bloomberg, TraderTV, Kitco and Barchart, to 31 December 2026
  • CEO.CA: C$80,000; Global One Media: US$6,500 a month; San Diego Torrey Hills Capital: US$7,500 a month
  • The Howard Group: C$10,000 a month and 250,000 options at C$0.20; it holds 650,000 shares

The Market One and Howard deals date from 31 March 2025, so both were running when the March study came out. Five of the other six were signed on 1 June 2026.

What to watch next for Allied Critical Metals

Monday 23 November is the first full session since the correction, as management attends the 121 Mining Investment Conference in London. Watch for the rewritten presentation and website, and for 20,000 metres of drilling planned for an updated resource and PEA in the first quarter of 2027; inferred material is just under 40% of the planned stopes.

Allied also applied for a Nasdaq listing on 12 August; the listing rules that separate OTCQB from Nasdaq show what that demands.

Investors can also set Borralha against Fireweed Metals' Yukon tungsten project.

Why did Allied Critical Metals retract its Borralha PEA claims?

On 20 November 2026 Allied retracted its "Robust" PEA wording and upside-led price cases after a British Columbia Securities Commission review, saying they suggested more certainty than a PEA allows.

Is the Borralha PEA still valid?

Allied is not restating the numbers: the base case stays at C$182.7m after tax at about US$704/mtu, now shown beside minus C$183.0m at US$400.

Who is paid to promote Allied Critical Metals?

Allied's 20 November release lists eight paid contracts, led by Native Ads (US$200,000), Market One Media (C$150,000) and CEO.CA (C$80,000).

Sources

Related stories

Aerial view of an exploration tent camp in pine forest beside a lake at Skyharbour's Russell Lake uranium project, Saskatchewan
Investing

Skyharbour Pays a Marketer US$150,000 Up Front as the TSX Venture Sinks 14.7% in a Week

Skyharbour Resources is paying US$150,000 up front for a 12-month investor campaign, while Alset AI will spend C$200,000 on social media, 30.7% of the C$651,500 it just raised.

Cut drill core from Brixton hole LM-26-480 at Langis, Ontario, showing grey cobaltite and native silver in a pale vein
Investing

Brixton Metals Drilled 142,770 g/t Silver, a Claimed Record. It Was 30 Centimetres Wide

Brixton Metals reported 142,770 g/t silver over just 0.30 m at Langis, Ontario, and 5 m at 704 g/t in a follow-up hole. Grade times width, true width and depth show what such…

A drill rig and crew on a rocky ridge at Koryx Copper's Haib copper project in southern Namibia, with desert hills behind
Investing

Koryx Copper's Haib Study Shows a $2.5bn NPV, Priced at $5 Copper

Koryx Copper's prefeasibility study values its Haib project in Namibia at $2.5bn after tax with a 25% IRR, on copper at $5.00 a pound, below this week's four-month low.

View north over rocky, wooded hills and old mine tracks at the Tempiute tungsten project in Nevada
Investing

Guardian Metal Resources Profile: Pilot Mountain, Tempiute and the Push for US Tungsten

Guardian Metal Resources has a finished study for its Pilot Mountain tungsten project and US$52.5m in cash, but still needs federal permits and about US$289m to build a mine in…

AMD's headquarters building at 2485 Augustine Drive in Santa Clara, California, photographed in March 2024
Investing

AMD Sheds 20.5% in a Week as a Short Seller Finds Its Code at a Blacklisted Chinese Firm

AMD shares fell 20.5% in a week to $424.39 after short seller Hunterbrook said AMD firmware kept reaching blacklisted Chinese server maker IEIT. AMD says the claims misrepresent…

Dell's glass-fronted headquarters building with the round Dell logo in Round Rock, Texas, in June 2015
Investing

Dell's $95bn AI Backlog Faces Thanksgiving Week's Big Test After a 42% Share Slide

Dell reports on Tuesday 24 November with a record $95bn AI server backlog after a 42% share slide, leading a Thanksgiving week of results from HPE, Medtronic, Workday, HP and…

Aerial view of a historical open-pit working beside a creek and gravel road on TDG Gold's Shasta property in north-central British Columbia
Investing

TDG Gold's C$1.18bn Shasta Study Assumes US$50 Silver, and Silver Just Closed at US$41

TDG Gold's first Shasta PEA shows a C$1.18bn after-tax NPV and a C$604.9m build cost, but it assumes US$50 silver, far above Friday's US$41.08 close, and leans on Inferred tonnes.

The old Toronto Stock Exchange building's stone facade on Bay Street, set into a dark glass tower
Investing

Copper's Slide to $12,765 Undercuts Lundin's Summer Price by 15% as Miners' Costs Rise

Copper fell as low as US$12,765 a tonne on 18 November, about 15% below the US$6.85/lb Lundin Mining realised in Q3, while First Quantum and Ero Copper raised their 2026 cost…