Skip to content
Economy

Warsh Sets Out Three AI Scenarios for the Fed, Including a Bust With Falling Shares

Fed chair Kevin Warsh set out three AI scenarios on Monday, one with falling shares and rising unemployment, as Cleveland Fed president Beth Hammack backed slow, steady rate rises.

The Marriner S. Eccles Federal Reserve Board Building in Washington, the Fed's headquarters, photographed in August 2008
Photo: AgnosticPreachersKid / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Kevin Warsh, chairman of the US Federal Reserve, on Monday 16 November set out three staff scenarios for how artificial intelligence could reshape the American economy, including one in which it disappoints, share prices fall and unemployment rises. On the same day Cleveland Fed president Beth Hammack said inflation was heading the wrong way and backed slow, steady rate rises, three weeks before the Fed's last meeting of the year.

The Fed on Monday 16 November

  • 3 AI scenarios drawn up by Fed staff, one ending in a slowdown and higher unemployment
  • 3.75% to 4% the Fed's main rate, held in October by a 10 to 2 vote
  • 7.8 the New York factory index, down 18 points, with prices paid easing to 45.9

Warsh sketched an AI boom, a jobs shock and a bust

Warsh was in San Francisco to open a conference of the Productivity and Jobs Task Force, one of five task forces he has convened as chairman. It was his first visit to a regional Reserve Bank as chairman, he said.

He called the technology "super intelligence", or SI, and described it as "an entirely new force in economic life and society". Fed Board staff have begun to test a range of outcomes using simplified, model-based frameworks. "These are illustrative scenarios, not forecasts," he said.

In the first, productivity rises and the gains are shared broadly between workers and the owners of capital. Growth runs persistently above its long-run average and the US stays close to full employment. In the second, growth is still strong, but some jobs are displaced rather than helped by the technology, and the jobless rate climbs above the level consistent with full employment.

The third matters most to shareholders. "Or SI could disappoint," Warsh said. "After significant capital investment and stock market gains, expected returns could turn down and equity valuations could fall, leading to an economic slowdown and a more notable rise in unemployment." He added: "In time, the economy would recover, but without the productivity gains."

He drew no conclusion for interest rates. "At the Fed, our role in all this is neither advocacy nor opposition," he said, adding that wide adoption of the technology would carry "important implications for monetary policy down the road."

The historic Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco building, listed on the US National Register of Historic Places, photographed in September 2016.
The historic Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco building, listed on the US National Register of Historic Places, photographed in September 2016. Photo: Niki Korth / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Hammack wants slow, steady rate rises

Hammack, who has a vote on rates this cycle, told Bloomberg Television that inflation was going in the wrong direction and that price pressures appeared to be broadening, according to an FXStreet account of the interview. Businesses, she said, were becoming more accepting of price rises and were passing more of them on.

Her answer is to raise rates slowly, in smaller steps, so the economy can adjust. Financial conditions, meaning how cheap and easy it is to borrow across markets, are still not restraining the economy in her view, so higher market borrowing costs are needed. The economy can cope with more restriction, she said, though it is unclear how far the Fed has to go.

On AI, she said the range of possible effects was very wide, and that technology investment was adding to inflation pressure.

She has already voted for a rise. On Wednesday 28 October Hammack and Governor Lisa Cook dissented from the 10 to 2 decision to hold the federal funds rate, the Fed's main rate, at 3.75% to 4%, preferring a quarter-point increase, the Fed's statement shows. That statement said inflation "remains elevated".

New York factories slowed and price pressure eased

The day's one hard number came from the New York Fed's Empire State Manufacturing Survey, a monthly poll of factories in New York State. A reading above zero means more firms reported improvement than decline.

Empire State survey, NovemberReadingMove from October
General business conditions7.8down 18 points
Number of employees18.1up sharply, highest since June 2022
Prices paid45.9down 14 points
Prices received27.2down 3 points
Capital spending plans23.0up 9 points, highest since December 2022

Source: Federal Reserve Bank of New York, responses collected 2 to 9 November.

Activity "increased modestly" after strong growth in October, the New York Fed said. Prices kept rising "at an elevated pace", but the 14-point drop in prices paid pointed to a "significant moderation" in input price increases. Hiring and investment plans point the other way, leaving the Fed a mixed picture.

The December meeting is the next test

The Fed's rate-setting committee meets on Tuesday 8 and Wednesday 9 December, its last meeting of 2026, and officials will publish fresh economic projections alongside the decision, according to the Fed's meeting calendar. Warsh stressed he was not making predictions, and Hammack said she goes into every meeting with an open mind.

How a Fed rate rise reaches households

  • Borrowers: the Fed raises rates when inflation runs above its 2% goal, lifting borrowing costs across the economy
  • Currency: higher US rates tend to strengthen the dollar, which matters for anyone holding US assets in euros or pounds
  • Shareholders: Warsh's third scenario is the one in which heavy AI investment and stock market gains give way to falling valuations

Warsh did not say the AI boom would end badly, only that the Fed is now planning for the possibility. "We can't know the future and ought not to pretend otherwise," he said.

Questions and answers

What did Kevin Warsh say about AI disappointing?

He said Fed staff had drawn up three illustrative scenarios. In one, AI disappoints after heavy investment, share prices fall and unemployment rises, before the economy recovers without the productivity gains.

Will the Fed raise interest rates in December 2026?

The Fed has not said. Its next decision is due on Wednesday 9 December. Cleveland Fed president Beth Hammack, who voted for a rise in October, said on 16 November that she favours slow, steady increases.

Sources

Related stories

Economy

Fed Raises Rates for the First Time Since 2023 as Warsh Calls Inflation Too High

The Federal Reserve raised its target range by a quarter point to 3.75 to 4 percent in a 12-0 vote, its first hike since July 2023, and 16 of 18 officials expect at least one more…

Economy

Fed, ECB and Bank of England: Where the Big Three Central Banks Stand Before December

The ECB has paused at 2.50%, the Fed held at 3.75%-4% with two votes for a hike, and the Bank of England has just raised rates to 4%. Where each stands on rates, votes and…

Economy

Fed Holds at 3.75%-4% in a 10-2 Vote as Two Officials Push for a Hike

The Fed held its range at 3.75 to 4 percent in a 10-2 vote, with Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack backing a hike, while the US 10-year yield rose above 5 percent as markets eyed…

Economy

Fed and ECB Warn the AI Boom Is Turning to Debt as Top AI Firms Head Past $800bn

Fed Governor Michael Barr said debt at the seven largest AI firms should top $800bn this year, as the ECB's Boris Vujčić said AI and sovereign debt now stand out among euro area…

Economy

Fed and ECB Warn the AI Boom Is Turning to Debt as Top AI Firms Head Past $800bn

Fed Governor Michael Barr said debt at the seven largest AI firms should top $800bn this year, as the ECB's Boris Vujčić said AI and sovereign debt now stand out among euro area…

Economy

China's Retail Sales Grow Just 0.4% in October as Investment Falls 8.1% and Exports Surge

China's retail sales grew just 0.4% in October and fixed-asset investment fell 8.1% over ten months, official data showed, leaving exports to carry an economy with weak demand at…

Economy

China's New-Home Prices Fell in 49 of 70 Cities in October as Resale Prices Slid in 58

New-home prices in China fell on the month in 49 of 70 cities in October and resale prices in 58, official data show, while retail sales grew just 0.4% as cautious households held…

Economy

Japan's Economy Shrinks at a 0.1% Annual Rate as BoJ's Takata Calls for Nimble Rate Rises

Japan's economy shrank at an annualised 0.1% in July to September, its first fall in a year, as prices hit shoppers. The same day BoJ board member Hajime Takata urged nimble rate…