Skip to content
Personal finance

Why Pump Prices Are Rising Faster Than Oil: Europe's Refining Squeeze Explained

Refining margins, not just crude, are driving Europe's peak fuel prices: Shell's indicative margin hit $42 a barrel in the third quarter, more than three and a half times the level a year earlier.

The skyline of Shell's Pernis refinery near Rotterdam, with its tall chimney, distillation columns and process units behind a grass field.
Photo: Steven Lek / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Diesel and petrol prices in the euro area reached new peaks in September, and crude oil explains only part of it. The bigger change this year is the margin refiners earn on turning crude into fuel, which has more than tripled from a year earlier as the Iran war disrupts Gulf supply.

What Goes Into a Litre at the Pump

A litre of diesel or petrol on a European forecourt is built in layers. The first is the cost of the crude oil. The second is the refining margin, the gap between what a refinery pays for a barrel of crude and what it earns selling the fuels made from it. Then come transport, storage, wholesale and retail costs, and finally taxes: a fixed excise duty per litre set by each government, with value added tax charged on top of everything else.

In much of the EU, taxes make up a large share of the final price. That has an odd effect. Because excise is fixed per litre, a 10 percent rise in crude does not mean a 10 percent rise at the pump. But it also means that when the layers below the tax line rise together, as they have this year, VAT turns every extra cent of crude and refining cost into a slightly bigger increase for the driver.

For most of the past decade, the crude layer did most of the moving. In 2026 the refining layer has become just as important, and for diesel it is arguably the main story.

Shell: share price, chart and news

A Shell Express fuel station at Pohjoisranta in Kruununhaka, Helsinki, in 2022, with its tall price sign listing fuel prices.
A Shell Express fuel station at Pohjoisranta in Kruununhaka, Helsinki, in 2022, with its tall price sign listing fuel prices. Photo: Pekka Vyhtinen / Helsinki City Museum via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

The Refining Margin Has More Than Tripled

The clearest public measure comes from Shell, one of Europe's largest fuel producers. Its global indicative refining margin, a benchmark of what a typical refinery earns per barrel processed, was $42 a barrel in the third quarter. That compares with $24 in the second quarter and $11.6 a year earlier.

PeriodShell indicative refining margin
Third quarter 2025$11.6 a barrel
Second quarter 2026$24 a barrel
Third quarter 2026$42 a barrel

Shell's third-quarter profit of $10.81 billion was almost double the $5.43 billion of a year earlier, and it raised its quarterly share buyback from $3 billion to $5 billion. Refiners are being paid handsomely for every barrel they can process, because buyers of finished fuel are competing for a smaller pool of supply.

Crude itself has risen too, but not by as much in proportional terms. When both the crude layer and the refining layer jump at once, the pump price rises faster than the oil price on its own would suggest. A driver comparing today's Brent headline with the forecourt sign is watching two separate price shocks stacked on top of each other, not one.

Europe's fuel squeeze in three numbers

  • $42 Shell refining margin per barrel, third quarter
  • 3.8% euro-area inflation, September
  • 2.5% ECB deposit rate, held on 29 October

Why Diesel Is Hit Hardest

Europe has long been short of diesel. Its refineries do not make enough middle distillates, the family of fuels that includes diesel, heating oil and jet fuel, to meet demand, so the continent relies on imports. Since the EU banned imports of refined products from Russia in 2023, a larger part of that gap has been filled by cargoes from the Middle East, India and the United States.

That is why the war that began in February matters so much at the pump. Gulf refineries are major exporters of diesel and jet fuel, and much of their output has to leave through the Strait of Hormuz or along the Red Sea. When that flow is disrupted, Europe has to bid for replacement cargoes against Asia and the Americas, and the price of finished diesel rises faster than the price of the crude it is made from.

The pressure has not let up. Every attack on refineries, export terminals or tankers in the region tightens the market for finished fuel, not just for crude, because a damaged refinery takes diesel off the market even when crude keeps flowing. Shell's own results show the knock-on effect on supply: its oil and gas output fell 17 percent in the first nine months of the year, largely because the conflict cut volumes from Qatar.

The effect is already visible in prices. Diesel and petrol in the euro area hit new peaks in September, according to the European Central Bank, the month in which euro-area inflation jumped to 3.8 percent from 3.2 percent in August.

How the Squeeze Reaches Household Budgets

Fuel is the most visible channel, but not the only one. Diesel moves almost everything that ends up on a supermarket shelf, so higher freight costs feed into food and goods prices with a lag. Households that heat with oil, common in parts of Germany, Austria, Belgium and Ireland, pay a price closely linked to diesel, just as the heating season starts.

The squeeze also shows up in interest rates. The ECB left its deposit rate at 2.5 percent on Thursday after raising it twice earlier this year. It said energy prices had risen above the path assumed in its September staff projections and that this is likely to push inflation higher in the near term and keep headline inflation well above its 2 percent target. For anyone with a variable-rate mortgage or a loan due for refinancing, that keeps borrowing costs higher for longer than looked likely at the start of the year.

The same pattern is showing up across the Atlantic. Around the Federal Reserve's meeting on 28 October, Tom Graff of the wealth manager Facet said the recent surge in diesel prices had not yet fully passed through to US consumer prices. If that holds in Europe too, some of the increase is still on its way into shop prices.

Why Pump Prices Can Lag on the Way Down

Drivers often notice that pump prices rise quickly when crude jumps and fall slowly when it eases, a pattern economists call "rockets and feathers". Part of the reason is stock: retailers price their next delivery, not the fuel already in their tanks. Part is the refining margin itself, which does not have to fall just because crude does.

That matters for the months ahead. A drop in crude prices on a ceasefire headline would help, but if refined fuel supply stays tight, the refining margin can absorb much of the relief before it reaches the forecourt.

What could bring pump prices down

  • A US-Iran agreement that restores normal tanker traffic through Hormuz and the Red Sea
  • An end to attacks on Gulf refineries, export terminals and tankers
  • Lower crude prices, which help only if refining margins fall at the same time
  • Weaker demand: high prices reduce driving and freight over time, which eventually cools margins
  • Fuel tax changes, which some governments use during price spikes, at a cost to public budgets

Three numbers tell readers most of what they need to know about where fuel bills go next. The first is Brent crude, the headline price. The second is the gap between diesel and crude prices, which measures how tight refined fuel supply is; refiners' quarterly results, such as Shell's, give a public read on it. The third is the euro-area flash inflation estimate, which shows how much of the fuel shock is reaching wider prices and shaping the ECB's next move.

For now all three point the same way. Crude is high, refining margins are far above normal and inflation is well above target. Until Gulf supply is restored, the pump price is likely to keep moving faster than the oil price alone would imply.

Sources

Related stories

Business

Shell Nearly Doubles Profit to $10.8bn as Refining Margins Soar

Shell's adjusted earnings rose to $10.8bn in the third quarter from $5.4bn a year earlier, beating forecasts, as its refining margin jumped to $42 a barrel. The quarterly buyback…

Markets

Schneider Electric Slumps 12% on Its $22.6bn PTC Bid as Oil Majors Gain 5%

Schneider Electric fell 12.08% on the week after agreeing to buy PTC for $22.6bn in cash. Shell, TotalEnergies and BP rose more than 5% as Hurricane Isaias shut most US Gulf…

Markets

Brent Settles Near $104 as Hurricane Isaias Shuts Gulf of Mexico Output

Brent crude settled up about 4 percent near $104 a barrel after Hurricane Isaias shut in about 1.3 million barrels a day of US Gulf of Mexico output while the Strait of Hormuz…

Markets

Brent Swings Around $100 as Iran Floats Reopening the Strait of Hormuz

Brent crude crossed $100 a barrel in both directions this week as Iran offered to reopen the Strait of Hormuz within seven days if Washington lifts its naval blockade and meets…

Personal finance

UK Mortgage Approvals Stuck Below 60,000 as Savills Sees House Prices Falling 1.5% in 2027

With fixed rates around 6 percent, UK mortgage approvals have been under 60,000 for five months. Savills now expects prices to fall 1.5 percent in 2027, led by London, as some…

Personal finance

Spanish Pensions Set for About a 3.5% Rise in 2027 as Inflation Holds at 4.9%

Spain's statistics office confirmed October inflation at 4.9 percent, locking in a pension rise of about 3.5 percent for January. The average retirement pension would gain some €55…

Personal finance

FCA Moves to Let Workplace Pensions Pay Performance Fees Outside the 0.75% Charge Cap

The UK regulator wants contract-based workplace pensions to pay private equity and venture capital performance fees outside the 0.75% cap on default funds. Responses are due by 14…

Personal finance

Diesel Still 32% Dearer Across the EU Than Before the Iran War, Even as Pump Prices Ease

The EU average diesel price fell 2.6% on the week to €2.097 a litre on 9 November, but it is still 31.6% above late February. Petrol is up 14.7%, and drivers in Finland and Denmark…